car techie

Custom Search

Accessories     Absorber      Air-conditioning     Alignment     Battery    Car news     Car photos     Carburetor     Clutch      Compression     Color      Converter    Disc brakes    Door    Engine    Gasket   Gear    Glass     Ignition     Light     Maintenance     Oil / fuel

<<Prev

Next>>



 
Buy a car
 
Chain versus belt

Question : WHAT are the advantages and disadvantages of chain and belt drive trains in terms of durability and maintenance costs ?

Also, the recirculating ball and nut verses rack and pinion.

Lastly, the common rail direct fuel injection versus the electrical fuel injection turbo diesel.

What are their advantages in terms of performance and cost of maintenance plus fuel economy ?

Answer : You cannot expect a detailed reply to such technical questions and so I will only give you a  brief reply to each :

1. To my mind, the chain drive is better than the belt drive for the camshafts.

Also, chains do not snap without warning and last almost forever.

However, the chain is noisy and it is more complicated to keep it in good tension.

Belts on the other hand are much quieter but must be replaced at regular intervals or else you could end up with very bent valves and even a scrap engine.

Belts are not cheap and usually replacing the belt also entails replacing the idlers and their hearings which can come up to quite a hefty sum.

2. The recirculating ball steering tends to be quieter and does not require as frequent adjustment as the rack and pinion.

Rack and pinion steerings have very limited adjustment and once that is taken up, the rack can make all sorts of noises.

Rack and pinion power steering units also have a higher tendency for leakage.

3. I think you are talking about a common rail system as opposed to a unit injector system.

I would prefer the common rail system for its efficiency and fuel consumption, although the operating pressures are much higher and there is a need to ensure that fuel used is clean.

 
 

Pulley change

Chain versus belt

Leaking seals

Saga upkeep

Faulty relay

Regular check-ups necessary

Faulty ABS

Vibration poser

Prius servicing cost

Overheating quandary

Service intervals

Coolant poser

Disturbing roar

Kancil vibration

Weird symptoms

Service schedule

Kembara blues

Fuel pump fault

Service dilemma

 

Maintenance 1

Maintenance 2

 

 

Others
 
Piston
 
Polishing
 
Rim
 
Roof
 
Sensor
 
Sound
 
Spark plugs
 
Spring
 
Stains
 
Steering
 
Suspension
 
Tappet
 
Timing belt
 
Tyre
 
Valve

     

Sites of similar field are welcome for exchanging links